Did blind auditions really get women into orchestras?

The famous study behind blind auditions said a screen raised a woman's chance of advancing from certain preliminary rounds by about 50%. That number rests on less than you would think. The controlled part covered only a small group who auditioned both with and without a screen, in three of eight orchestras. In that subset, screens seemed to help women in preliminary rounds but men in semifinals. Critics, including Christina Hoff Sommers, say the paper's own significance tests were weak. Women did join in larger numbers. They were about 5% of players in the top five US orchestras in 1970 and about 25% by the late 1990s. The study credited screens with about 30% of that rise among new hires. Blind hiring elsewhere has cut the other way. A 2017 Australian trial of more than 2,000 managers found that hiding candidate details made women less likely to be shortlisted.
Sources: nber.org, independentwomen.com